• Media type: E-Article
  • Title: The impact of financial statement comparability on earnings management: Evidence from frontier markets
  • Contributor: Martens, Wil [Author]; Yapa, Prem W. S. [Author]; Safari, Maryam [Author]
  • imprint: Basel: MDPI, 2020
  • Language: English
  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijfs8040073
  • ISSN: 2227-7072
  • Keywords: frontier markets ; real earnings management ; accounting comparability ; accruals earnings management
  • Origination:
  • Footnote: Diese Datenquelle enthält auch Bestandsnachweise, die nicht zu einem Volltext führen.
  • Description: This paper examined whether financial statement comparability constrains opportunistic earningsmanagement in frontiermarket countries. Using a large sample of 19 frontiermarket countries, and an accounting comparabilitymethod thatmaps comparability across several accounting standards, the results show that enhanced financial comparability constrains accruals earnings management (AEM). Contrary to developed markets and novel to this study, a significant relationship between financial comparability and real earnings management (REM) was not found. For greater robustness, AEM and REM were also tested on both International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) adopting and non-adopting countries. The results suggest IFRS adoption constrains AEM, yet exhibited no impact on constraining REM. Additionally, the use of BigN auditors failed to conclusively show an ability to moderate EM.When combined, the results suggest that frontier markets engage in less REM than expected. It is also noted that the legal roots (civil vs. common law) play a significant role in constraining earningsmanagement. Common law countries exhibited lower AEMwhen comparability increased; this significance was not found in countries that were rooted in civil law. Contributions from this study show that findings from developed markets cannot be generalised to frontier markets.
  • Access State: Open Access
  • Rights information: Attribution (CC BY)