You can manage bookmarks using lists, please log in to your user account for this.
Media type:
E-Article
Title:
From hostile worlds to multiple spheres: towards a normative pragmatics of justice for the Googlization of health
Contributor:
Sharon, Tamar
Published:
Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2021
Published in:
Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 24 (2021) 3, Seite 315-327
Language:
English
DOI:
10.1007/s11019-021-10006-7
ISSN:
1386-7423;
1572-8633
Origination:
Footnote:
Description:
AbstractThe datafication and digitalization of health and medicine has engendered a proliferation of new collaborations between public health institutions and data corporations like Google, Apple, Microsoft and Amazon. Critical perspectives on these new partnerships tend to frame them as an instance of market transgressions by tech giants into the sphere of health and medicine, in line with a “hostile worlds” doctrine that upholds that the borders between market and non-market spheres should be carefully policed. This article seeks to outline the limitations of this common framing for critically understanding the phenomenon of the Googlization of health. In particular, the mobilization of a diversity of non-market value statements in the justification work carried out by actors involved in the Googlization of health indicates the co-presence of additional worlds or spheres in this context, which are not captured by the market vs. non-market dichotomy. It then advances an alternative framework, based on a multiple-sphere ontology that draws on Boltanski and Thevenot’s orders of worth and Michael Walzer’s theory of justice, which I call a normative pragmatics of justice. This framework addresses both the normative deficit in Boltanski and Thevenot’s work and provides an important emphasis on the empirical workings of justice. Finally, I discuss why this framework is better equipped to identify and to address the many risks raised by the Googlization of health and possibly other dimensions of the digitalization and datafication of society.