You can manage bookmarks using lists, please log in to your user account for this.
Media type:
E-Article
Title:
The problem of equal moral status
Contributor:
Miklosi, Zoltan
Published:
SAGE Publications, 2022
Published in:
Politics, Philosophy & Economics, 21 (2022) 4, Seite 372-392
Language:
English
DOI:
10.1177/1470594x221091285
ISSN:
1470-594X;
1741-3060
Origination:
Footnote:
Description:
<jats:p> A central puzzle of contemporary moral and political philosophy is that while most of us believe that all or almost all human beings enjoy the same moral status, human beings possess the capacities that supposedly ground moral status to very unequal levels. This paper aims to develop a novel strategy to vindicate the idea of moral equality against this challenge. Its central argument is that the puzzle emerges only if one accepts a usually unstated theoretical premise about value and the proper response to value. The premise holds that if the presence of a valuable property warrants a certain kind of response towards its bearers, then every variation in the degree to which the property is present necessarily constitutes a reason for a corresponding variation in the response that is warranted towards its bearers. It argues that despite its intuitive appeal, the premise is not plausible as a general view about the proper way of responding to value, and as a view about responding to the value of rational beings in particular. It proposes an account of the proper manner of valuing rational beings that supports a distinctive version of the so-called threshold approach to justifying equal moral status. </jats:p>